The Root Word: ForestEthics Blog

Press Release: ForestEthics Advocacy Challenges Harper Government Energy Rules in Court

Aug 13, 2013

A democracy should encourage public participation, not curtail it

Last spring, the federal government of Canada, led by Prime Minister Stephen Harper, labeled ForestEthics an enemy of the state and tried to shut us down. While they continue to push their toxic tar sands agenda and do their best to bully and intimidate scientists, environmental organizations and citizens into silence, our message is this: We Won't Be Silenced.

Today, ForestEthics Advocacy is doing what we do best – standing up to Canada’s government with a lawsuit challenging laws passed last year that unreasonably restrict the rights of everyday Canadians to have their say on proposed oil projects.  This violates citizens' rights to free speech and puts our natural environment at risk.

Read our press release from today's press conference in Toronto announcing our lawsuit:

MEDIA CONTACT: Sarbjit Kaur,, 416-274-5324


Toronto—ForestEthics Advocacy and Donna Sinclair, represented by renowned civil rights and constitutional lawyer Clayton Ruby, are suing the federal government over new rules that restrict citizen participation in public decisions about the energy industry.

The application, filed in Toronto today, calls for the Federal Court of Canada to strike down provisions of the National Energy Board Act that unreasonably restrict public comment on project proposals. ForestEthics Advocacy and Ms. Sinclair are also challenging new rules created by the National Energy Board (NEB), which prevent any discussion of the wisdom of tar sands development at the upcoming Enbridge Line 9B hearings.

The NEB regulates the oil, gas, and electricity industries and approves pipeline construction, coal and uranium mining, liquified natural gas projects, and tar sands development in Canada. Its decisions have massive environmental and health implications. Under the new rules, many Canadians are blocked from participation.

“Through legislative changes snuck into last year’s Omnibus Budget Bill C-38, the Conservative government has undermined the democratic rights of all Canadians to speak to the issues that impact them,” explained Mr. Ruby. “Right now, they cannot question the development of the tar sands itself! We're challenging the legislation and the NEB’s new rules because they violate fundamental free speech guarantees enshrined in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.” 

Recent legislative changes mean that many Canadians with something to say about these projects will not have their chance to be heard. The NEB now requires that anyone wanting to submit a letter of comment to the NEB must complete a nine-page application for a chance to speak at NEB hearings. The NEB then decides who can and cannot provide testimony. The NEB reserves for itself the right to exclude anyone except for those that it considers to be “directly affected” by the proposed project. 

“The amendments not only restrict who can speak to issues before the National Energy Board, but they also limit what those individuals are allowed to say,” said ForestEthics Advocacy board member Tzeporah Berman. “Canadians deserve a fair public debate about the future of our economy and energy systems. Right now, they aren't getting it.”

Under the new rules enacted by the Harper government, Donna Sinclair’s request to submit a letter of commet at upcoming hearings for the Enbridge Line 9b hearings in Toronto was denied. Sinclair is an author, long-time member of the United Church of Canada and a feature writer for the United Church Observer.

“Tightening the rules around public participation to the extent that any citizen of this country-–regardless of expertise or geographical location-–cannot express their concerns is an extraordinary and profoundly dangerous affront to our democracy. I love my country and my beliefs call on me to respect our environment. That is why I chose to join this lawsuit,” says Sinclair.

Quick Facts

  • This is the first time the amendments will be challenged in court.
  • This suspension of citizen speech is effective:  In 2012, 1544 people spoke at NEB hearings for the Enbridge Northern Gateway pipeline project. Only 175 are permitted to speak at hearings this year for the Enbridge Line 9B reversal project.
  • ForestEthics Advocacy was founded in 2012 to stand up for the rights and health of Canadians and the country's natural environment. 

For a backgrounder please see PDF icon 

Ben West of ForestEthics Advocacy

By Ben West, Tar Sands Campaign Director, ForestEthics Advocacy

More by Ben West:

stay connected

Latest Tweets

Hot Topics

#BlackLivesMatter #StopOilTrains #ThereIsNoNeutral Action Recap action report back Alberta Alberta Climate Change Plan American Greetings art & activism art + activism bay area BC BC's coast Blast Zone Bomb Trains british columbia Bunker Spill burnaby mountain California Californians Against Fracking canada Canadian Lawsuit caribou china clean energy future climate change Coal COP21 crude by rail crude oil Delta 5 Dogwood dot 111 Earth Day Ecosystem Based Management Enbridge English Bay environmental justice events exploding oil trains fair trade Ferguson first nations Forestry Standards Fortune Minerals fracking freedom train free trade FSC G7 get inspired get the shell out Gitga’at nation Governor Inslee Greenbuild green divas greenwash Haida Gwaii Imperial Metals Institutional Racism just for fun kalamazoo river spill Kinder Morgan Klabona Keepers Lac-Mégantic LEED lobbyists mindfulness mining blockades Mount Polley national geographic natural gas NEB NEB Lawsuit net neutrality no FIPA Northern Gateway no tankers NTSB obama oil by rail oil spill oil train regulations oil trains paper policy Paris Agreement Paris Climate Talks paul colangelo pcm peatlands people's climate march Philips 66 Phillips 66 pipelines Pope Frances Rachel Notley Racial Injustice Rainforest Solutions Project Ralph Nader refineries responsible economies responsible resource development richmond sacred headwaters sacred waters safe oil trains San Luis Obispo SFI sierra club SLO SOS Day of Action Staff Stories Tahltan take action Tarsands Invasion Tar Sands SOS Transportation Safety Board tree geek United Nations Wespac white house Why We Do Our Work wild salmon